4.6(36 reviews)quality
why it ranked: The top quality pick near BYU-I, at 4.6/5 from verified reviews. Love it 10/10 every time! Absolutely love it here!
20 min walk to BYU-I$538/person/moCaring management10/10 would recommendSafeGood maintenance
Find My Place AwardTop Quality · 2026
The 12 Top Quality Student Apartments Near BYU-I (October 2026)
Brigham Young University – IdahoRexburg, IDUpdated Monthly
By the FMP Data Team · Reviewed October 1, 2026
60 properties reviewed
408+ reviews analyzed
updated October 2026
independentno pay-to-rank
the short answer
The Landing leads our October 2026 ranking of the 12 Top Quality student apartments near BYU-I with a 4.6/5 quality score, followed by The Gates at Rexburg and The Colonial House. Across the 60 properties reviewed, students keep coming back to unit condition and building upkeep: the quality signals that move a property up this ranking. Browse all off-campus housing near Brigham Young University – Idaho for every option.
- winnerThe Landing
- quality range3.4–4.6 / 5
- avg walk16 min to campus
- rent range$206–$1855 /person
the ranking
The 12 Top Quality Student Apartments Near BYU-I
Sorted by quality score from verified BYU-I reviews, high to low. Scores reflect current BYU-I reviews only.
4.4(42 reviews)qualitywhy it ranked: A podium finish for quality near BYU-I, 4.4/5 from verified reviews.
The Gates townhomes are chef’s kiss! So much space and storage areas, private bathrooms for every room you only share with one other person, in-unit laundry..etc. You can definitely tell…
24 min walk to BYU-IWorth the money10/10 would recommendCaring managementGood maintenance
4.2(36 reviews)qualitywhy it ranked: A podium finish for quality near BYU-I, 4.2/5 from verified reviews.
I had to clean a little bit when I moved in but overall it was fine. I have enough storage space with the shelves and drawers underneath my bed. I keep some food items in my room just so…
10 min walk to BYU-I$500/person/moGreat locationCaring management10/10 would recommendGood roommate matching
3.8(29 reviews)qualitywhy it ranked: Holds a 3.8/5 quality score from verified BYU-I reviews.
Here’s a friendly, honest quality-focused review: The quality of the apartments is really nice. They are a little older, so they…
5 min walk to BYU-I$463/person/moGreat locationCaring managementGood maintenanceSafe
3.4(21 reviews)qualitywhy it ranked: Holds a 3.4/5 quality score from verified BYU-I reviews.
The apartments are clean, and they have high standards for cleaning checks.
15 min walk to BYU-IGreat locationGood maintenanceCaring managementGood roommate matching
5.0(6 reviews)qualitywhy it ranked: Holds a 5.0/5 quality score from verified BYU-I reviews.
Apartments are clean and are always being updated.
14 min walk to BYU-I$1605/person/moCaring managementWorth the moneyGreat locationBest in town
4.4(5 reviews)quality33 min walk to BYU-I$206/person/mo
The Full Ranking, One Table
Sort by any column. The rank stays with the property.| fmp score | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Landing | 4.6/5 | 4.6 | 36 | 20 min | $538/mo |
| 2 | The Gates at Rexburg | 4.4/5 | 4.2 | 42 | 24 min | – |
| 3 | The Colonial House | 4.2/5 | 4.4 | 36 | 10 min | $500/mo |
| 4 | University Courtyard | 3.8/5 | 3.9 | 29 | 5 min | $463/mo |
| 5 | The Pines | 3.4/5 | 4.0 | 21 | 15 min | – |
| 6 | NorthPoint Apartments | 5.0/5 | 5.0 | 6 | 14 min | $1605/mo |
| 7 | Piano Casa | 5.0/5 | 5.0 | 5 | 11 min | – |
| 8 | Alta View | 5.0/5 | 5.0 | 5 | 21 min | – |
| 9 | East Triplex | 5.0/5 | 5.0 | 5 | 11 min | – |
| 10 | Heartland Apartments | 4.4/5 | 4.4 | 5 | 33 min | $206/mo |
| 11 | Brenchley | 4.0/5 | 4.0 | 5 | 19 min | – |
| 12 | Rose Casa | 4.8/5 | 4.8 | 5 | 11 min | – |
Walk times are door-to-door to BYU-I campus. Rent is per person, per month.
FMP award criteria
How We Ranked These Apartments
1
Ranked by quality
quality score, high to low. That’s the whole ranking. Verified reviews rate it 1–5, and recent reviews count more than older ones. Ties go to the property with more reviews.
2
Who Makes the List
Every property near BYU-I can appear, but it takes a minimum number of verified reviews to rank by score. Under-sampled properties sit below every qualified one, ordered by review count, and move up automatically as reviews come in.
3
The FMP Score
The composite score in the full table: quality plus management and quality from verified reviews only. Useful context, but it doesn’t affect the order. Rankings are independent: there’s no way to pay for placement.
by the numbers
What Makes an Apartment ‘high-quality’ Near BYU-I
We ran every verified quality review for BYU-I-area apartments through theme analysis. These are the themes students bring up most when a place feels high-quality, by share of the reviews that mention them.
Unit condition
56%
Building upkeep
38%
Amenities
11%
Based on AI analysis of verified BYU-I quality reviews, refreshed monthly. Percentages show the share of reviews that mention each theme; most reviews mention more than one. See our complete BYU-I review data →
browse the awards
Other Best-Of Rankings Near BYU-I
each fmp ranking re-ranks the same properties by a different lens (management and quality among them) and keeps its own list, refreshed monthly.
fmp award
Best Overall
The highest-rated all-around: the best overall score across social scene, management, and quality.
see the ranking →fmp award
Most Social
The most active social scenes: shared spaces, resident events, and roommate matching, scored from verified reviews.
see the ranking →fmp award
Best Management
The most responsive, reliable landlords: maintenance turnaround, lease transparency, and deposit fairness.
see the ranking →faqs
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the top quality student apartment near BYU-I?
The Landing leads our October 2026 ranking of the 12 Top Quality student apartments near BYU-I with a 4.6/5 quality score, followed by The Gates at Rexburg and The Colonial House.
How is this ranking calculated?
This list is ranked by one number: each property's quality score from verified reviews. Students rate a property's quality 1 to 5, and we average those scores, counting recent reviews more heavily than older ones. No self-reported data from landlords.
What makes an apartment high quality?
In reviews, the highest quality scores come from well-kept units, a building that’s clearly maintained, and amenities that actually work as promised.
How often is this ranking updated?
Monthly. We re-pull verified reviews and re-score every property at the start of each month, so the order reflects the most recent 24 months of student feedback. The “updated” date at the top of the page shows the latest refresh.
How many reviews does a property need to be included?
There's a minimum number of verified reviews to rank by score, and we don't publish the exact bar so it can't be gamed. Properties under it still appear, below every qualified property and ordered by review count, so a 5.0 from one review never outranks a 4.5 from thirty. Once a property collects enough reviews, it moves into the scored ranking automatically.
Is this ranking independent, or can properties pay to rank higher?
It's fully independent. There's no pay-to-rank. Position is set by verified reviews alone. Property managers can't buy placement, remove reviews, or influence the score.
for property managers
Made the List? Get Your FMP Award Badge.
If your property is on this ranking, you've earned an FMP Award. Reach out and we'll set you up with the official badge for your website, social, and print, free. It's how renters know your ranking is real.
Find My Place Award2026
11st place
Top Quality
student apartments near BYU-I
Verified & independentBrigham Young University – Idaho · Rexburg, ID
more housing resources for BYU-I
Keep Going
share this ranking